SAS-Space, for world class research

Latest additions

Abstract

Visual Reasoning in Euclid’s Geometry: An Epistemology of Diagrams


It is widely held that the role of diagrams in mathematical arguments is merely heuristic, or involves a dubious appeal to a postulated faculty of “intuition”. To many these have seemed to exhaust the available alternatives, and worries about the status of intuition have in turn motivated the dismissal of diagrams. Thus, on a standard interpretation, an important goal of 19th Century mathematics was to supersede appeals to intuition as a ground for knowledge, with Euclid’s geometry—in which diagrams are ubiquitous—an important target. On this interpretation, Euclid’s presentation is insufficient to justify belief or confer knowledge in Euclidean geometry. It was only with the work of Hilbert that a fully rigorous presentation of Euclidean geometry became possible, and such a presentation makes no nonredundant use of diagrams. My thesis challenges these claims. Against the “heuristic” view, it argues that diagrams can be of genuine epistemic value, and it specifically explores the epistemology of diagrams in Euclid’s geometry. Against the “intuitive” view, it claims that this epistemology need make no appeal to a faculty of intuition. It describes in detail how reasoning with diagrams in Euclid’s geometry can be sufficient to justify belief and confer knowledge. And it shows how the background dialectic, by assuming that the “heuristic” or “intuitive” views above are exhaustive, ignores the availability of this further alternative. By using a detailed case study of mathematical reasoning, it argues for the importance of the epistemology of diagrams itself as a fruitful area of philosophical research.Philosophy of Mathematics, Epistemology & Methodology

Norman, Alexander Jesse (2008) Visual Reasoning in Euclid’s Geometry: An Epistemology of Diagrams. PhD thesis, UNSPECIFIED.


Item Type:Thesis (PhD)
Subjects:Philosophy
Keywords:Euclid, Visual Reasoning, Diagrams, Intuition, Hilbert, Mathematical Reasoning
Divisions:Institute of Philosophy
Collections:London Philosophy PhD Theses
Deposited By:Repository Administrator
Date Deposited:08 Oct 2010 11:33
Last Modified:12 Oct 2010 07:44
ItemID:1121
Files available for downloadg
[img]
Preview
FilenameJesse Norman - PhD Thesis.pdf
File size653Kb
Download
License termsAvailable to public
Comments Notes Tags All

Comments

Add a Comment


Close comments

Notes

Add a Note - this will be visible to you alone, while you are logged in.

Note title [optional]:

Close notes
Tag this item (You may enter a comma separated list):
Close tags

padlock
Repository Staff Only
Item control page