SAS-Space, for world class research

Latest additions

Abstract

Scholasticism, Liberalism, Revolutionary Nationalism and Neoliberalism in Mexico


This paper attempts to sketch out a history of the (loosely) scholastic tradition that I encountered through ethnographic research in contemporary west Mexico, including its historical relation to the statist liberal tradition about which so many scholars have written. I asked my informants what it meant to them to be citizens. During the interviews, my informants sometimes talked of citizenship as a relationship with government, usually of individuals and mediated by rights. However, many were reluctant to reduce citizenship to a relationship with government, replying instead that citizens were, unlike hermits, people who lived in society, ideally in a civil way. In responding thus my informants sounded Aristotelian and I suggest that civil sociality had made its way via Aquinas and later scholastics such as the Jesuit Suárez and thence via colonial missionaries to modern Mexico. There it has offered, I suggest, one way of combating the statist liberalism that first developed in the mid-nineteenth century (and which included priests – hence my reluctance to conflate Catholic with scholastic). I am endeavouring to test and add nuance to that crude account. For one thing, the scholastic and liberal traditions have crossed over at certain points. My informants shifted from one notion of citizenship to the other, even within the space of an interview. The same was true of the most obvious source of their ideas about citizenship - the Civics textbooks used since the Revolution. The textbooks included chapters on liberal schemes of individual rights but invariably began with a chapter on the inescapable sociality of the person, also citing hermits as the antithesis. The paper therefore tries to tease out earlier points of contact between the scholastic and liberal traditions, in the long nineteenth century.

Stack, Trevor (2012) Scholasticism, Liberalism, Revolutionary Nationalism and Neoliberalism in Mexico. In: Liberalism and Religion: Secularisation and the Public Sphere in the Americas, 18 April 2012, Senate House, London. (Unpublished)


Item Type:Conference or Workshop Item (Paper)
Subjects:History
Sociology & Anthropology
Keywords:Liberalism, Scholasticism, Citizenship, Mexico, Nationalism, Neoliberalism
Divisions:Institute of Latin American Studies
Collections:Liberalism in the Americas
Deposited By:Deborah Toner
Date Deposited:14 Aug 2012 14:40
Last Modified:13 Aug 2013 10:00
ItemID:4171
Files available for downloadg
[img]FilenameLIA,_Scholasticism_and_Liberalism,_Stack,_18.04.12.pdf
File size720Kb
Download
License termsAvailable to public
[img]FilenameLIA,_Scholasticism_and_Liberalism,_Stack,_18.04.12.pdf
File size720Kb
Download
License termsAvailable to public
Comments Notes Tags All

Comments

Add a Comment


Close comments

Notes

Add a Note - this will be visible to you alone, while you are logged in.

Note title [optional]:

Close notes
Tag this item (You may enter a comma separated list):
Close tags

padlock
Repository Staff Only
Item control page